Movie : Kurukshetra
Language : Malayalam
Date : 10th Oct,2008
Review:
The ‘Mindset’
I have always felt that while watching a war movie, the reviewer should always keep his patriotism aside, till at least the end credits start rolling. Especially, if it’s a war movie involving India, I always make it a point that I keep a control on the patriotic quotient rising inside me and don’t allow that to judge the movie. This is because, after all, every war film is a ‘movie’. And we are here to judge how good the movie is at the end of the day and not the patriotism (which is undoubtedly always good). The patriotism should only act as a supplement while making the final judgment about the movie.This is exactly the same mindset I had when I started to watch ‘Kurushetra’.
The ‘Movie’
Now, on to the movie. ‘Kurushetra’ definitely has its moments. And I truly believe that moments make a war movie (even more important than for a normal movie). Those moments which pack a punch in your hearts. In such movies, you know that these ‘moments’ are being well planned and plotted. For example, when the character Bineesh (Chotta) and his watch come in to reference in the first half, you clearly know that it’s a plot being made for some war ‘moment’ involving him in the second half. Similarly for the soldier who collects ‘Milk Maid’ bottles and the soldier who sends money to build his ‘home’ and so on. But that’s perfectly fine, when something is being done in a good way you tend to give the reigns of your mind to the director and float along on his ways.
Major Ravi has succeeded in many of these so called ‘war moments’. He has gone beyond the ‘usual limits’ to pack those punches. These moments come back to you even after the movie. For Example - The corpse of the soldier who sends money to build his house is taken and kept inside his newly finished house before cremation, is truly going ‘beyond the usual limits’ to pack the punch. So even if you expected the ‘plot’ but this breach of limits is a surprise. I frankly thought that this cremation scene would end where the shot of the new house was shown. Ravi went beyond to leave a mark.
The scene where Mahadevn and team bury the Pak corpses with full honor is another impressive scene. They are wrapped in Pak flags and using proper rituals. Again beyond the limits and packing the punch.
The ‘Milestones’
There are 2 milestone moments which are the clinchers for me. First is at the start of the movie and the Second at the very end. I will elaborate on these.As the movie starts, the scenic Kashmir is shown and credits starts rolling in. Everything looks normal and as usual credits go on till the one for the ‘Producer’. The movie goes on after that. The credit for the ‘director’ doesn’t come immediately. A border confrontation with Pak military is shown. An Indian Soldier is shot and as he falls his cap flies in the air. Freeze!. On the screen we have the cap tumbling in the air and the blue sky in the backdrop. And then the director’s credit appears. Wow, that’s a moment for you!!!
The second one is when you feel that war is over and everything is won. Mahadevan calls his commander and says that his team won’t retract back and leave the 17kms which they have caught in the battle. He says that if he is ordered to return that land for which 13 of his soldiers have died then he would himself die that moment. That’s a clincher for me.
With this movie, Ravi has shown us that he is deeply love with the subject that he is filming and also he has improved a director by leaps and bounds.
The fighter jet’s shoot down sequence in the first half and the last 20 minutes of war sequences are top notch.
The cinematography is good but not as impressive as ‘Keerthichakra’.
Music is fine and evokes the right kind of emotions. ‘Jwalamukhi’ is my pick. Background score is competent.
The ‘Minuses’
Ravi has got many things going right but at the same time he has got many things going wrong as well. When many of those soldier stories evoke some sort of compassion they still don’t choke your heart. And some don’t leave an impression.Just read this situation. As corpses are being carried back to the basement during the battle, a lady army doctor awaits to certify each of them as dead. She and her husband (who is also on the battle filed) have been away from each other due to their fight over careers. She has got her posted to the battle field to meet him. Unknowing that he is one among the batch of corpses she opens the file to sign the corpses as dead. Stop!
Impressed? I think you might be. But just see this piece of story in Kurushetra and it has been reduced to tale which doesn’t create the same impact. Mainly because Biju Menon (who plays the above husband) never evokes any compassion in the story. He is just there for the sake. And the worst is the lady who plays the wife. She is so plastic that it will make you shudder in despair. How could the director commit such a casting blunder?
The same goes for the story of Manikuttan and his lover army nurse. First of all, he never has a part that leaves an impression and secondly the lady actor is pathetic.
Also, the audience is not given a picture on the progress of the war. The terrain and strategy is discussed by Mahadevan once in detail. That’s all. Its never brought in to the picture as the war progresses. Like how many posts captured and how much is left etc? Some clever strategy planned etc. None of this happens. The only saving grace is Siddique’s last cunning act using the communal tag.
Also, as the movie beings we are irked to see that everyone in the team is a Mallu. There is only one Punjabi shown and a few North east guys here and there. As Mahadevan speaks to his non mallu superiors (during the war plan sequence) many a times he does it in Malayalam and they seem to be nodding. This language problem keeps irking your senses much throughout the first half.
In the forum, there were some views of it looking as a documentary. I didn’t get this feeling any point in time.
Regarding performances most of them are competent. Also it’s a refreshing change to see some young people instead of the usual Malayalam war movies with heavily pouted middle aged men in the army.
The role is a cake walk for Mohanlal. He is competent but comes to his own in the last scene which I spoke in the beginning. I liked him in that scene and evoked compassion. But his Hindi is poor. I liked his body language better in Keerthichakra.
The ‘Finale’
After a long review, now to the verdict. Kurushetra is a good movie. It impresses in many parts and many things could have been better as well. I feel that its below the first Ravi movie, Keerthichakra. For me it features among the better movies of the year…. TK, KS, PMT, TP, VOB and MB in that order.
For moments that pack a punch and quite a few of them for that matter. For many casting misses and many things that could have been explored like war tactics etc (only Ravi could have done it).
With all this, I have a 3/5 and A Verdict : Good for Kurushetra.
Go and give your heart out to those ‘moments’ which will pack punches in your psyche!!.
Movie : Thalappavu
Language : Malayalam
Date : 28th Sep, 2008.
Review
Many Movies are always comparable to others for some reasons. 'Thalappavu' and 'Thirakadha' are movies like that. Not because I saw them back to back but I think even if these 2 movies were released years apart, I guess they would have been compared. I will tell you why. The most obvious reason can be that both movies have Prithviraj but my strong case are other reasons.
1. Both follow a narrative pattern which keeps shifting between different periods in time.
2. Both movies are towards serious in nature.
3. When we begin watching Thirakadha, we feel that its Prithvi's story and by the end of it we know that Malavika stole the show and she keeps haunting you days after the movie. In the very same way, from the start, Thalappavu looks like Lal's story but Prthivi is the guy who comes back to your memories when you first think about Thalappavu, days after you have watched it.
Now to the movie.
Thalappavu is a good work of cinema and it stays just as that. It is 1 hour and 45 minutes in length and the first half is just 45 minutes. The story and the ambience is nice. Photography is good. Direction is good as well considering that Madhupal is a first timer.
As usual, no discussions about story in the review
I have a few things that I have noted about this movie. I think as a viewer, the movie is a bit too serious, almost to the brink of being branded as a so called 'art movie'. In direct contrast, Thirakadha was also serious but it was a more interesting watch even at 2.5 hrs length.
I think the Script could have been better. The reason is that few minutes in to the movie, the whole sequence of events can be guessed and after that there are no surprises except for some power packed scenes by Prithvi and Lal.
But I am not taking anything away from Thalappavu. Its a good movie experience for serious movie lovers. Lal's performance is good and as expected. I expected the same kind of performance from him and thats what I got. The girl who acts as Lal's childhood love is surprisingly good and her transition from teenage to adulthood is nicely potrayed by her.Rohini was loud in some scenes.
The scene stealer for me is Prthivi. He has fire in his eyes and potrays his character well. There are some scenes or shots of Prithvi shown as Memory shots about prithvi which Lal thinks. All those scenes come in detail in the second half. All of the are brillant especially the one in which he extends a hand to Lal to get him up from where he has fallen in a stream. His face shines with light in that scene.Also his smile and attitude are that of a revolutionary who knows what he is doing is right. But his hair do and the wig used needs some bettering.
The references to Jesus Christ are poignantly done. I really liked that. The first scene when the part from bible is being read where Judas betrayes Christ and the person who betrays Prthivi walks out. And Prithvi looking at Jesus's sketch in the market. All those are scenes of substance and director needs applaud. I think he wanted to potray the naxalite as a noble man by showing references like these.Violence part is a totally different issue.
Music is OK for the movie. There is only 1 song but background music is competant.
I think Thalappavu deserves credit but it could have been much better. May be some people would like it this way.But for me, I felt that it could have been more entertaining (not the comedy, song ,dance kind but Thirakada kind of serious entertainment). There is nothing much of a suspense or some events that surprise you as the movie progresses. The appearance of Prthivi as spirit with scar on his face does scare you a bit. That too only for the first time but the moment he (in his spirit avatar) starts making long dialogues on the corruption in today's system, I think even that surprise element is lost.
But I am not going to take anything away from it. Its a good movie and much better than so called masala movies off late in Malayalam.
RATING : I am going with 3/5 and a tag - "STRONGLY RECOMMENDED FOR SERIOUS CINEMA LOVERS" for Madhupal's Thalappavu.
This Onam is truly is the brightest that 'Malaylam cinema' has shone for years !!!
Movie : Thirakadha
Language : Malayalam
Date : 20th Sep, 2008
Review:
Initial Thoughts
Long after I had finished watching the movie 'Thirakadha', I had this question in my mind (which was also hotly debated in this forum) about who is the hero of the movie. For a first few seconds, I felt that it was Anoop but my mind refused to rule Prithvi out. Then I felt the opposite that Prithvi is the hero but again my mind could not rule out Anoop. And while all this was going on, I felt that I should reinvent the question. After all is it that necessary to decide who the hero of a movie is?? I don't think so.
For 'Thirakadha' as a story and a film, there are 3 main characters. Akki (Prithvi),Ajayan(Anoop) and Malavika(Priya Mani) and of these 3, two are male and one is a female character. The whole point I am trying to make is, here is a movie which cuts away from the stereotype. Why can't we just live with the fact that here is a movie which has 2 so called 'heroes' and a 'heroine' without a usual triangle.Yes, I think an audience only gets a kind of movie that it deserves. And we should start to show some maturity as an audience to accept that all movies should not necessarily have only 1 final hero and 1 heroine.
Ok now to the movie, Thirakadha. Undoubtedly its the best Malayalam movie I have seen this year. I would rank it way above VOB, PMT and Madambi. I have the reasons for it.
Strengths
The first reason is a refreshing premise for a plot. Secondly the performances. Thirdly the script, screenplay and direction.The story has been widely discussed in the forum so I am not going in to it. The first half is nice and clean. I don't think it’s boring neither is it too good as well. But the second half takes the movie to a different level.The post deterioration images of Malavika are stunning, disturbing and engrossing. The back ground score is haunting and effective throughout the movie.
Director's corner
The script has a nice pace which is required for this movie. Direction is competent. Screenplay is good but i have a suggestion for Renjith. The scene in which Ajayan sees Malavika in the hospital, as he enters the camera should have taken shot of Malavika as seen by Ajayan once and then pan to Ajayan's reaction. Now, the reaction is first shown and Anoop has not done that desirably well. The same reaction has been handled well by Prthivi when he peeks in to Malavika's hospital room in Nagercoil.
Performances
Anoop as Ajayan
About the performances, first about Anoop as Ajayan, my rating as 3rd best performance in this movie. I think i didn't like him in the first half. I felt that they shud have reversed the roles. Prithvi shud have been Ajayan and Anoop shud have been Akki. May be Prithvi wanted to avoid the backlash of him imitating the superstars etc. But by the second half, I guess Anoop manages to ooze confidence. He brings the mannerisms of the 2 Ms in a very suttle manner in some shots which is good but fails at some critical scenes like the shot at the hospital discussed above. Overall good,competant and tad unexpected.
Prithvi as Akki
The 2nd best performance by a very narrow margin to Prithvi as Akki. ‘WOW’ dats the only word I have got to describe him in the movie. His performance as the writer in serach of a story is superb. His best scenes are with Anoop in his caravan and the one which he says to Samvratha that he has become the part of the story that he was seraching for and as its real life he cud not control the script of the same.Prithvi, Are you listening??And now a personal message to Prithvi. When I saw u in Nandanam, I felt that u were just a young boy. When I saw u in vellithira, I hated you. When i saw your interviews, I hated you more. I felt that here was a overconfident man who is out to dethrone my 2 personal prides (the 2 Ms, I like them immensley). But with Classmates, Chocolates and few other movies, you made me sit up and take notice. I always felt that watever it may be, Prithvi can never make the 2Ms to admire something that he has done. It can only be the reverse. But now I feel that I have been proven wrong and how!!!!!. I am happy that you are in the 20s, the same as I am.(I will grow along and see you becoming the superstar). I am happy that you will be the future of Malayalam cinema. With 'Thirakadha', you have not only put in a stupendous performance but has given more to the movie than just mere acting. For giving directors the strength to make such themes, and to stand back and take the role of the writer and not Ajayan. I salute your spirit!!!
PriyaMani as Malavika
Lastly, the best performance of the movie. Charming Seductress to a Haunting image, Priyamani delivers a knock out performance as Malavika. It’s a refreshing change from Meera Jasmine, who is sterotyped in 'Dukhaputri' roles and is screaming and shouting all around (Though I have liked some of her performances). Priyamani does a bit of overacting in some of the first half scenes but that can be granted as potraying the young age of the actress. I really don't find anything much objectionable in the movie. She is bold, vulnerable and admirable all at the same time. Tell me another Malayalam heroine (Nayanthara included) who would have done this role in 'malayalam'(not in tamil). Her dubbing is top notch (Don't know if she has done it herself). She has a haunting smile that stays with you even after the movie. When she appears first time on screen as cancer struck and the old smiling shot of hers is shown, I literally had goose bumps. What a cinematic moment!!!!
Weakness
Negatives - The music is a big letdown. None of the songs are catchy. After a lot of thinking, I guess Alphonse (coz of Big B) or even Jayachandran (coz of Akale) wud have done better for this theme. Even Laptop had better songs than this movie.And I didn't find the first night song objectionable. There are more vulgar songs in Tamil and Hindi movies which are being shown on Tv umpteen times a day. This song has been aesthetically done.And I heard in a TV interview in which Priyamani said that Prithivi had roped her in for the role saying that it’s the role of a lifetime. Prithvi's involvement in the movie much beyond his own role is quite evident in the final movie.
Audience
And finally, the icing on the cake. The audience. They were silently watching throughout the movie. There were no boos or kooval for any silent scenes,. Can you believe that?? And finally the clincher, there were claps from the audience at the end of the show. I literally I couldn’t believe whether I was watching the movie in Kerala. Many guys walking out were telling their friends that they liked it. I felt that finally we are growing out of Alibhais and Annan Thampis.
Rating - So after a long review, 4/5 and 'MUST WATCH FOR SURE' tag for Thirakadha’.
We need a change in Malayalam cinema and we need to be the torch bearers for it. So find some time and go and watch this sincere attempt to change things for the better.Watch it and applaud this effort for a change in Malayalam cinema.Remember -"An Audience only gets that cinema which it deserves". Lets cultivate the culture of better cinema.